Why Your Child Begs to Be Scared (And Why It's Good for Them)

Picture a haunted house in Denmark, complete with dark hallways, costumed actors, and perfectly timed jump scares.

Now picture more than a hundred visitors walking through it while wearing heart rate monitors.

That's exactly what researchers at Aarhus University's Recreational Fear Lab set up. In a 2020 study published in Psychological Science, Marc Malmdorf Andersen, Mathias Clasen, and their colleagues tracked visitors (ages 12 to 57) through the Dystopia Haunted House. They recorded heart rates throughout, filmed faces at three jump-scare spots, and asked visitors to rate how scared they felt and how much fun they had at each one.

The big question was simple: does more fear mean more fun?

Actually, not quite.

Enjoyment climbed as fear went up, but only to a point. Past that point, more fear meant less fun. The researchers described the pattern as an upside-down U, with “a sweet spot” in the middle where enjoyment peaked.

Heart rates told a similar story. The most enjoyable moments weren't the calmest ones or the most intense ones. They were the moments when the body's response was, in the researchers' words, “just right.”

The haunted house study focused on teens and adults. So the same lab turned to children.

In a 2025 study in Child Psychiatry & Human Development, Mihaela Taranu and colleagues surveyed 1,600 Danish parents about their children, ages 1 to 17. Parents reported that 93% of children enjoyed at least one kind of scary-but-fun activity. About 70% did one at least once a week, and roughly 1 in 5 did one every single day.

Here's the surprising part: horror movies weren't the favorites.

Across every age, the most popular thrills involved speed, height, or depth, like swings, slides, and rides. Younger children leaned toward chase games, hide-and-seek, and scary pretend play. Scary books, shows, and games became more popular as children got older.

So the preschooler squealing “Again!” after a big swing push and the fifth grader begging for one more ghost story are doing the same thing. They're playing with fear.

Why would a brain go looking for a feeling designed to keep us away from danger?

The Aarhus researchers describe recreational fear as a “low-cost, risk-free experience with fear.” A haunted house lets your child feel the pounding heart, the sweaty palms, and the urge to bolt, and then discover they can ride it out. Nothing is truly at stake. That's the whole point.

In the 2025 study, the team suggests that choosing to face manageable fear may help children learn their own limits and build coping skills. They're careful to call this an idea worth testing, not a proven result. But it fits with a larger body of research on play that we'll dig into below.

In other words, the begging isn't a sign that something is off. More often, it's a sign your child is ready to practice.

There's a flood of AI news right now, and most of it is written to scare you or hype something up. But what if there was a way to get the AI news without the spin?

That’s exactly what this free newsletter does. Every morning, they send you the AI news worth knowing and explain why it actually matters for your life and job. After one week of reading this, you'll know where AI really stands, where it's heading, and which headlines are actually worth paying attention to.

It’s called The Rundown, and over 2 million professionals from companies like Apple, Google, and NASA already read it daily.

Sign up for free

If there's a sweet spot, the natural next question is: where is it?

The honest answer is that it's different for every child, and it moves as they grow. Even in the haunted house study, the sweet spot varied from person to person. One detail stood out, though. Visitors who came because they wanted to, rather than being dragged along, reported having more fun.

What scares a child also changes with age. Media researcher Joanne Cantor, who spent years studying children's fright reactions at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, found that for younger children (roughly ages 2 to 7), how something looks matters most. A friendly monster with a frightening face can still be terrifying, and “it's not real” doesn't help much at that age. Between about 8 and 12, appearance matters less, and children become more likely to be rattled by things that could really happen.

With that in mind, here's how to help your child find their own “just right.”

Let your child hold the remote. Choice is a big part of what makes fear fun. Offer real control: a pause button, the lights on, a seat closest to the haunted house exit. Knowing there's a way out is often what keeps a scare in the play zone.

Watch the body, not just the words. Giggles, squeals, peeking through fingers, and “Do it again!” usually mean your child is right in the sweet spot. Going quiet, freezing, or clinging that doesn't ease up are signs the scare has tipped past fun. That's a cue to dial it down, not a failure.

Match the scare to the stage. For younger children, think silly monsters, a parent “chasing” them around the yard, and costumes that look more goofy than gory. Older children may love a spooky story but feel uneasy about a realistic news-style plot. Previewing a movie or book ahead of time can make all the difference.

Turn the dial slowly. A daytime corn maze before a nighttime trail. A mildly creepy book before a scary movie. When the last level starts to feel easy, your child is probably ready for the next one.

Stay close. In the 2025 study, younger children mostly enjoyed scary activities with parents, caregivers, or siblings. The researchers point out that trusted companions help scary moments feel safe. Sometimes the best safety net is just sitting on the couch together.

Even with the best planning, some scares will overshoot. Cantor's research offers a helpful guide here.

For younger children, comfort works better than logic. A hug, a warm drink, the lights on, or a change of scenery will usually help more than an explanation.

For older children, talking it through helps. Explaining how a movie scene was made can take some of the scare away. For worries about things that could actually happen, honest reassurance works better than insisting it would “never” happen. Cantor found that arguments about how unlikely something is tend to fall flat.

At every age, the thing children want most is a parent's sincere, focused attention. Once things have calmed down, a few simple questions can turn a rough moment into a learning moment: “What was the scariest part? What did your body do? What helped?”

When a child is scared, the instinct to step in is strong. Skip the spooky aisle, turn off the movie, take the long way around the house with the inflatable skeleton.

It comes from a loving place. But researchers who study play see it differently: a little fear might be worth keeping.

In a 2011 paper in Evolutionary Psychology, Ellen Sandseter of Queen Maud University College and Leif Kennair of the Norwegian University of Science and Technology took a close look at thrilling, risky play.

Their idea goes like this. Young children naturally develop certain fears, like a fear of heights, that protect them while they're too young to handle those situations. Thrilling play, like climbing higher than last time or zooming down a steep slide, brings children face to face with what they fear while filling them with excitement instead of dread. As their skills grow, the fear fades.

The researchers call this the “anti-phobic” effect of thrilling experiences. They also raise a flip side: when children are kept from age-appropriate thrills, those early fears may stick around longer than they need to.

The authors present this as a hypothesis, not a settled fact. But others have built on it.

In 2021, psychologists Helen Dodd and Kathryn Lester published a model in Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review describing how adventurous play might lower a child's risk of anxiety.

When children climb trees, ride bikes fast downhill, or jump from rocks, they wrote, children “experience feelings of fear and excitement, thrill and adrenaline.” Through those moments, children practice a racing heart, not knowing exactly what will happen, and handling it anyway. Dodd and Lester hypothesize that, over time, these learning opportunities may reduce a child's risk of developing anxiety.

A haunted house walk-through and a backyard tree climb aren't identical, of course. But they share the same core ingredient: real fear in a safe setting, with the choice to keep going.

None of this means forcing a hesitant child into a haunted house. Remember, choice is part of what makes fear fun. The goal is simply not to close the door when your child knocks.

Say yes to the small stuff. The mildly spooky library book. Flashlight stories in the living room. A costume that's a little scary.

Explain what the body is doing. “Your heart is pounding! That's your body getting ready. It's doing its job.” Children feel braver when they can name a feeling and explain why.

Point out the courage afterward. “You were scared, and you kept going anyway.” That one sentence can shape how your child sees themselves.

Treat “not this year” as a valid answer. If your child opts out, that's okay. Try again next season, or try something a step milder.

Here's the bigger picture. Learning to feel uncomfortable, stay with it, and come out the other side is a skill that reaches far beyond Halloween. It shows up the first time your child raises their hand without being sure of the answer, or keeps working on a math problem that doesn't click right away. A haunted house might just be one of the most fun places to start practicing.

We’re asking parents like you to share their thoughts on topics that matter each week! Cast your vote and see what others think! We’ll chat more about the results next week. 👀

The costume is ready. The candy bowl is full. And your child has just spotted the haunted house at the fall festival, the one with the long line and the screams drifting out the exit.

The catch? It looks like it might be a few notches past their “just right.”

Now that we know the sweet spot is real, we're curious how this moment plays out at home. What's the move?

For the child who loves a good scare (and the parent figuring out how much is just right), these resources help keep the spooky stuff in the fun zone.

Common Sense Media: Age-based reviews of movies, shows, books, and games, with detailed notes on scary content. A quick preview before movie night makes it much easier to match the scare to your child's stage.

Goosebumps by R.L. Stine: A classic first step into scary reading for elementary schoolers. Creepy enough to deliver real chills, silly enough to stay fun, and easy to put down when your child needs a break. Scholastic's parent guide rounds up favorites from the series.

Hey Warrior by Karen Young: This picture book explains the amygdala as a brave, protective part of the brain that sounds the alarm when it senses danger. Written for children who wrestle with anxious feelings, it's also a helpful way for any child to understand why their heart pounds during a scare.

Thinkster Math: The same skill that gets a child through a haunted house, feeling unsure and pushing forward anyway, is what helps them tackle a tough math problem. Thinkster pairs your child with a dedicated, live math coach who sets challenges at just the right level, so struggling feels safe and every win feels earned. AI-driven insights track progress over time, while the human coach keeps every step personal.

The next time your child begs for something scary, it might be worth hearing that request a little differently.

That giggle-scream in the haunted house hallway is your child practicing one of life's most useful skills: feeling afraid and finding out they can handle it. With some choice, a gentle dial, and a trusted grown-up nearby, a good scare can be more than a Halloween tradition.

We'd love to hear how spooky season looks at home. Does your child ask for a scary movie, book, or tradition every year? Hit reply and tell us!

Thanks for joining us in raising kind, capable, and confident humans. We’re so glad you’re here.

❤️ Loved this issue? Have thoughts, questions, or topic ideas?

Share your vote below or drop us a note at [email protected].