The Two Words That Teach Kids Nothing About Accountability

You already know a forced sorry feels hollow.

Turns out, your child likely knows this too.

A 2018 study published in the Merrill-Palmer Quarterly found that children of all ages can distinguish between a willing apology and a coerced one. And here's the part that might surprise you: in the study, children actually rated the offender as less likable after a forced apology than before. The person being apologized to felt worse, not better, after receiving one.

That's not a parenting failure. That's just what happens when we skip the internal work and go straight to the words.

Here's why.

When your child hurts someone, and you immediately prompt them to say sorry, their brain isn't processing the impact of what they did.

It's processing the social pressure of the moment - the embarrassment, the eyes on them, the desire to just make this stop. They're too busy managing their own discomfort to actually feel anything about the other person's.

Dr. Craig E. Smith, whose research on children and apologies is among the most-cited in this space, put it plainly: coercing a child to apologize will backfire.

Not sometimes. Reliably.

And the Greater Good Science Center at UC Berkeley adds another layer to this:

When parents and educators push children to forgive and apologize immediately, both parties feel compelled to skip the phases of genuine remorse - the uncomfortable but necessary work of actually understanding what they did and why it mattered.

None of this means we stop guiding children toward accountability. It means we're guiding them toward the wrong thing when we stop at the word.

The goal was never "say sorry." The goal was to repair.

Those are not the same thing.

The difference between an apology and repair:

An apology is a word.

Repair is a process.

Research from the University of Connecticut describes repair as the act of returning to a moment of disconnection, taking responsibility, and genuinely understanding the impact of your actions on the other person.

Importantly, researchers distinguish this from a standard apology, noting that a good apology often tries to close a conversation and move on, while repair opens one up.

That's a meaningful distinction for parents. When we hand our children a script and consider the matter resolved, we've closed the conversation. We haven't actually opened the door to the connection, accountability, and growth that we were hoping for.

The children who develop strong repair skills - the ones who grow up to be genuinely accountable, empathetic adults - aren't the ones who were drilled on "say sorry."

They're the ones who were walked through what actually happened, helped to understand the other person's experience, and given room to figure out how to make it right.

That takes longer. It's less tidy in the moment… but it's the thing that actually sticks.

Intrepid Travel has just launched its new Premium Family range — eight new trips across Costa Rica, Sri Lanka, India, Borneo, Vietnam, Morocco, Thailand and Egypt. Small groups of three to five families. Intrepid's most experienced local guides. Immersive, kid-focused activities and elevated stays, with all the logistics handled for you. Watch baby orangutans learn to climb in Borneo. Stargaze at a desert camp in Morocco. Spot leopards on safari in India. These aren't holidays where you watch the world through a window — they're the kind of trips kids remember when they're grown up. Bookings for Intrepid's Family range grew 19% in 2025, and their new Premium tier is their fastest-growing travel style for good reason.

Explore Premium Family trips

So if "say sorry" isn't enough, what is?

The research points to a few consistent components in apologies that actually repair rather than merely resolve surface tension.

1. Acknowledgment of the specific behavior

Not "I'm sorry if you're upset" - which, by the way, is not an apology, it's a deflection. A real repair starts with naming what actually happened. "I knocked over your tower when you were almost done building it." Specificity matters here, and not just for the recipient. When your child is specific about what they did, they're forced to actually think about it. That thinking is where empathy begins.

2. Recognition of impact

This is the part that truly separates a genuine repair from a performance. It requires your child to hold the other person's experience in their mind. What did it feel like to be on the receiving end? Why did it matter to that person? Even preschoolers, research shows, can do this with some guidance - and it's a skill that develops with practice.

Try: "How do you think your brother felt when that happened? He'd been working on that tower for a really long time."

3. Remorse - real remorse, not performed remorse

This one can't be scripted. But it can be cultivated. The difference is timing and approach. A child who's still in the heat of the moment, still amped up or defensive, isn't ready to feel genuine remorse - their nervous system won't allow it. Waiting until they're calm, and then coming back to what happened, creates the conditions for something real to surface.

4. Restorative action

Here's the piece that research consistently highlights as one of the most powerful. Even preschoolers respond better to a wrongdoer who offers to make something right with action - helping rebuild the block tower, drawing a new picture to replace one that was ripped, or sitting with someone who was left out. Action communicates accountability in a way that words alone don't.

Dr. Craig E. Smith's work found that even very young children value restorative action and respond positively to it. When your child asks, "Is there something I can do to make it better?", they're practicing a relational skill they'll use for the rest of their life.

5. A genuine commitment to do differently

This doesn't need to be a grand declaration. It can be simple. "Next time I'm frustrated, I'll walk away instead." But articulating it out loud - even to a five-year-old - builds the neural pathway that makes a different choice more likely next time.

A note on timing:

None of this works in the heat of the moment. When your child has just hurt someone, the first goal is to attend to the person who was hurt. The second is to give your child time to come down from whatever state they were in. The repair conversation happens after - when everyone can actually think.

This is actually good news, because it takes the pressure off the immediate aftermath. You don't need to engineer a meaningful apology in the next thirty seconds. You need to come back to it when the conditions are right.

Here's the part of this conversation that tends to land quietly.

The research on how children develop genuine repair skills consistently points to one of the most powerful predictors: watching their parents do it.

Not perfectly. Not dramatically. Just genuinely.

When your child watches you say, "I was wrong to snap at you this morning, that wasn't fair," - actually, specifically, with no defensiveness and no rushing past it - their brain is building a template.

This is what accountability looks like.

This is what it sounds like.

This is what people I respect do when they hurt someone.

The neuroscience here is compelling. Research from trauma-informed psychology describes what happens in a child's nervous system when a rupture - a moment of conflict, disconnection, or harm - is followed by genuine repair.

The cortisol drops. The amygdala quiets. And the child's developing brain learns a foundational lesson: conflict is survivable. Relationships can hold mistakes. The people who hurt me can also come back and make it right.

That template - built over thousands of small repairs across a childhood - is what becomes a secure adult. Not a perfect childhood. A repaired one.

Bessel van der Kolk, the psychiatrist and trauma researcher, writes extensively about how unresolved relational experiences live in the body. The flip side of that is also true: resolved ones do too.

Every time you come back and make a genuine repair with your child - for your raised voice, your distracted response, your impatience - you are actively shaping their nervous system's relationship with conflict.

And when they watch you do it with other adults in their lives? Same effect. You're showing them, not just telling them, that repair is what people of character do.

Practical ways to model repair with your child

The most powerful thing you can do to raise a child who knows how to genuinely apologize is to genuinely apologize to them.

Markets move. Headlines catastrophise. But somewhere inside the noise is the story that matters — the opportunity, not the fear. 

The Daily Upside was built by Wall Street insiders to find it — global business and finance, reported without the alarm.

Join 1M readers →

Last week, we asked:

When your child loses or faces a big disappointment, what's your instinct in the first few minutes?

Here’s how you voted:

🟨🟨🟨⬜️⬜️⬜️ 🔹 I try to comfort them right away and reassure them it's okay (20%)
🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩🟩 🔹 I give them a little space before saying anything (40%)
🟨🟨🟨⬜️⬜️⬜️ 🔹 I acknowledge the feeling & stay close without trying to fix it (20%)
🟨🟨🟨⬜️⬜️⬜️ 🔹 Honestly, I'm not sure - I'm still figuring out what works best (20%)

What stood out most in this poll is that parents seem to be moving away from immediately fixing disappointment and toward simply being present with it. The truth is, there is no perfect response! Every child, and every disappointment, is different. Sometimes the most helpful thing we can do is resist the urge to make the feeling disappear and instead communicate, "I'm here when you're ready."

We’re asking parents like you to share their thoughts on topics that matter each week! Cast your vote and see what others think! We’ll chat more about the results next week. 👀

1. Seek by iNaturalist (App) Summer is the perfect time to turn every backyard, park, and hiking trail into a science lab. Seek lets your child point their phone at any plant, bug, bird, or fungus and get an instant ID, pulled from a database built with the California Academy of Sciences and National Geographic. No account required, no data collected, no social sharing. Just genuine curiosity rewarded in real time. Kids who spend summers with this app tend to come back to school with a vocabulary for the natural world that their classmates genuinely don't have.

2. Thinkster Math (App + human coaching) Summer is the single biggest window for math gains outside the school year, and also the biggest window for losing them. Thinkster pairs AI that tracks exactly where your child's thinking goes off track with a real human coach who actually knows your child. Not a chatbot, not a generic curriculum. If your child struggled with fractions in May, they won't still be struggling in September. The summer start is especially useful because there's no homework pressure competing for their attention.

3. PhET Interactive Simulations (Web, free) Built by the University of Colorado Boulder, PhET lets kids run actual scientific experiments in a browser, no equipment required. It quietly builds the kind of scientific thinking that standardized tests reward, without feeling like test prep at all.

4. Libby (App, free with library card) The most underused tool in any parent's phone. Libby connects directly to your local library card and gives your child free access to thousands of ebooks and audiobooks, including most titles on summer reading lists. The audiobook feature is especially useful for kids who resist sitting down to read but will listen for an hour on a car ride or while drawing. Summer reading loss is real, and Libby is the zero-cost, zero-friction fix.

Two words don't build a skill. Genuine repair does.

The good news is that your child doesn't need to get this right at age four. Or seven. Or even ten. Repair is a practice - one that develops over years of small moments, patient guidance, and watching the adults around them do it with honesty and care.

The next time your instinct is to say "say sorry," try this instead: attend to whoever was hurt, give your child some time to settle, and come back to it. Ask them what happened. Ask them how they think the other person felt. Ask them what they could do to make it a little better.

That's the whole thing, actually. Not a script. A conversation.

And if you mess up the conversation? Repair that too.

Thanks for joining us in raising kind, capable, and confident humans. We’re so glad you’re here.

❤️ Loved this issue? Have thoughts, questions, or topic ideas?

Share your vote below or drop us a note at [email protected].