Are Our Kids Learning to Think or Just Learning to Keep Up?

One parent shared that her child no longer seems to enjoy school.

Another described a schedule packed with advanced coursework, music, sports, early mornings, and late nights, yet still wondered, “Am I missing something?”

Many parents are doing everything they were told would help their children succeed.

Enrichment. Structure. High expectations. Full schedules. Support at every turn.

And yet, a quiet frustration lingers.

Kids are completing assignments, but freezing when something feels unfamiliar.

They are busy, but not confident.

Capable, but hesitant.

This is the paradox of modern childhood. Productivity has increased, but ownership has not.

When kids move from task to task with little space to reflect, struggle, or problem-solve on their own, learning can start to feel like something that happens to them instead of something they participate in. They learn how to comply, not how to think.

This does not mean structure is bad. It means structure without autonomy can crowd out independence.

One subtle sign this is happening is when kids immediately ask, “Is this right?” or “What do I do next?” before trying. Another is when they shut down quickly at the first sign of difficulty. The message they absorb is not “I can figure this out,” but “Someone else will tell me.”

A helpful shift for parents is to pause before stepping in. Instead of giving answers right away, try questions that invite thinking.

These questions slow the moment just enough to give kids space to engage their own thinking.

Independence does not grow from doing more. It grows from being trusted with the process, even when it is messy, slow, or uncomfortable.

Stop losing nuance when you type prompts. Wispr Flow captures your spoken reasoning, removes filler, and formats it into a clear prompt that keeps examples, constraints, and tone intact. Drop that prompt into your AI tool and get fewer follow-up prompts and cleaner results. Works across your apps on Mac, Windows, and iPhone. Try Wispr Flow for AI to upgrade your inputs and save time.

Try Wispr Flow

Another parent shared something many families quietly carry. Her child struggles academically, does not retain information well, and has never learned to persist through difficulty. Over time, those struggles became something more painful.

Low confidence.

Second-guessing.

A deep mistrust of their own instincts.

This is how struggle turns into self-doubt.

Kids are not born believing they cannot do hard things. That belief forms when effort does not seem to lead to progress and when mistakes feel like evidence rather than information.

When kids experience repeated difficulty without support that helps them understand why they are struggling, they often internalize the problem. Instead of thinking, “This strategy is not working,” they think, “I am not good at this.”

Confidence does not come from constant success. It comes from surviving a challenge and realizing you can keep going.

Parents can help shift this narrative by changing how struggle is framed. Instead of focusing on speed or correctness, focus on process.

These moments teach kids that struggle is not something to avoid, but something to learn from.

It is also important to normalize frustration. Many kids believe that feeling stuck means something is wrong. Hearing a calm, “This part is supposed to feel tricky,” can be incredibly grounding.

When kids learn that difficulty is part of learning, not a verdict on their ability, confidence slowly rebuilds. They begin to trust themselves again, not because things are easy, but because they know they can handle hard moments.

Technology, advanced academics, and constant stimulation have changed how kids learn and how they see themselves.

One parent shared a powerful concern. If kids never have to think deeply, reflect, or sit with themselves, who are they becoming?

This is not a fear of technology. It is a fear of losing agency.

Independent thinking requires space.

Space to make choices. Space to reflect. Space to be bored enough to wonder, question, and imagine.

In a world that fills every gap, parents often have to intentionally protect that space.

One small but powerful habit is allowing kids to struggle privately before offering help.

Not forever, but long enough for them to engage their own thinking.

Another is carving out quiet, unstructured time with no goal to achieve. No performance. No productivity. Just time to be.

Parents can also model independent thinking out loud.

Sharing how you weigh options, rethink decisions, or change your mind shows kids that thinking is a process, not a performance.

Raising independent thinkers does not mean stepping away.

It means shifting from director to guide.

When kids feel trusted to think, question, and decide, they do more than keep up.

They begin to own their learning, their choices, and eventually, themselves.

A successful retirement can depend on having a clear plan. Fisher Investments’ The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income can help you calculate your future costs and structure your portfolio to meet your needs. Get the insights you need to help build a durable income strategy for the long term.

Download Your Free Guide

Last week, we asked parents what worries them most right now.

The clear majority shared that their biggest concern isn’t that their child is falling behind or burning out…

It is that their child is not learning how to think independently.

What stood out most were the stories behind the votes. Parents are noticing pressure without joy. Struggle without confidence. Full schedules without space to reflect.

You are not alone in this concern, and asking these questions means you are already paying attention to what matters most!

We’re asking parents like you to share their thoughts on topics that matter each week! Cast your vote and see what others think! We’ll chat more about the results next week. 👀

Independent thinking is not something kids suddenly develop one day. It is built slowly, through reflection, trial and error, and moments where there is no single “right” answer.

This week, we are inviting parents to think less about adding more and more about creating space.

Journaling does not need to look like paragraphs on a page. For many kids, a sentence, a drawing, or a quick voice note works just as well.

Try prompts like:

The goal is not eloquence or depth. It is helping kids notice their own thinking and experiences.

Many kids are used to games where the fastest answer wins. Balance that with activities where there is no timer and no single solution.

Look for games and puzzles that:

During play, resist the urge to coach. Let kids wrestle with decisions and talk through their thinking afterward.

Here are some games to check out: Rush Hour, Story Cubes, Outfoxed, Castle Panic, and Katamino.

Reflection does not need to be formal. A few calm minutes at the end of the day can make a big difference.

Try simple check-in routines like:

Keep it low pressure. No fixing. No correcting. Just listening.

These moments help kids connect their experiences to their own thoughts, which is the foundation of independent thinking.

Many parents are not worried because their kids are failing. They are worried because their kids are capable, busy, and still unsure of themselves.

That concern comes from care, not fear.

You are raising humans who will one day need to think for themselves, trust their instincts, and choose who they want to be.

That work does not always show up on a report card, but it matters deeply.

Thanks for joining us in raising kind, capable, and confident humans. We’re so glad you’re here.

❤️ Loved this issue? Have thoughts, questions, or topic ideas?

Share your vote below or drop us a note at [email protected].